Today I want to talk about a critique I see all the time in the horror community. You see it in reviews, Reddit threads, BookTube comments—people asking for recommendations that will finally, actually, really scare them, like there’s one perfect book out there that’ll do the trick.
Some seem to have bought into marketing and literally want a white-knuckled thrill-ride of scares… and that might just be impossible.
Fear is incredibly personal, and what terrified one reader might feel totally flat to someone else. And more importantly most seasoned horror readers aren’t actually looking to be scared every time. This is just the genre and the themes they enjoy. It’s not always about fear—it’s about atmosphere, tension, projection, characters, and dark imagination.
So I’ve pulled together seven reasons why horror novels might not be scaring you anymore—and why that’s not necessarily a bad thing.
Let me know in the comments what the last book was that genuinely creeped you out—or if like me, you think horror doesn’t have to actually scare you to be great.
Books mentioned:
Grimm’s Fairy Tales
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark
In a Lonely Place by Karl Edward Wagner
Sundial by Catriona Ward
The Haunting of Velkwood by Gwendolyn Kiste
Clown in a Cornfield by Adam Ceasar
Heads WIll Roll by Josh Winning
The Terror be Dan Simmons
House of Leaves by Mark Z. Danielewski
The Rats by James Herbert
Gone to See the River Man by Kristopher Triana
Woom by Duncan Ralston
Dead Inside by Chandler Morrison
The Summer I Dies by Ryan C. Thomas
Slob by Rex Miller
Pressure by Jeff Strand
We Used to Live Here by Marcus Kliewer
Starling House by Alix E. Harrow
Skeleton Crew by Stephen King
Small Town Horror by Ronald Malfi
✮✮✮✮✮✮
▹ Bookworm Central on Patreon ▹ https://www.patreon.com/typicalbooks
▹ Bookworm decor is here! ▹ https://shop.typicalbooks.com/
▹ All socials, the shop and news ▹ https://linktr.ee/LydiaPeever
▹ Read books I wrote ▹ https://amzn.to/3k20OY6
▹ A list of horror books out each month ▹ https://typicalbooks.com/newhorror
▹ Music by ænorex ▹ https://aenorex.com
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases when you use Amazon links here. While I accept very limited and specific books for review from publishers, my reviews are honest, and I only accept books I’d have bought with my own money.
If I’ve been recommended a book it might be on my Amazon Wishlist here : https://www.amazon.ca/hz/wishlist/ls/2OB0ZQMS0YGT9
I talk horror books; extreme horror, classic, slasher, gothic, and everything in between. Helping you find the next best horror book to read is the goal, and sharing new and old horror from my shelves and new releases is how! Horror, nonfiction and even true crime can be found here as I find that human beings are the scariest thing of all.
✮ Thank you! ✮